AccommodationPre-ProductionBeginningIntermediateHigh IntermediateAdvanced

Manipulatives

Manipulatives are physical, movable objects (base-ten blocks, counters, fraction tiles, algebra tiles, letter or syllable cards, magnetic words, pattern blocks, models, and three-dimensional realia) that emergent bilingual students touch, group, build, and rearrange while reasoning about academic content. They lower the language demand of a task by letting students show and construct understanding through action before they have to encode that understanding in English. In second-language acquisition terms, manipulatives make grade-level content more comprehensible by adding a concrete, context-embedded layer to cognitively demanding work, so students can engage with rigorous concepts while their English is still developing. They function as a temporary scaffold that is faded as students gain the language to reason verbally and symbolically.

When to use it

Use manipulatives when a concept is cognitively demanding but can be represented physically (place value, operations, fractions, area, sentence structure, phoneme or syllable segmentation, life cycles, states of matter, sequencing events). They are especially valuable when introducing new content, when students at earlier proficiency levels would otherwise be blocked by unfamiliar academic vocabulary, and during small-group or hands-on practice. They also support formative assessment, letting a teacher see what a student understands conceptually even when the student cannot yet explain it in English. Manipulatives should be deliberately faded once students can reason accurately with representational drawings and abstract symbols, so the objects remain a bridge rather than a permanent substitute for symbolic and verbal reasoning.

How to implement it

  1. 1Select manipulatives that map cleanly onto the target concept and onto students' existing knowledge (for example, base-ten blocks for place value, syllable cards for segmentation), so the object carries meaning that language otherwise would.
  2. 2Model the manipulative explicitly with a think-aloud and clear gestures, naming each action and object in English (and in the home language or through a peer when available) so students hear the academic language attached to the concrete referent.
  3. 3Pair every physical action with targeted language: provide sentence stems and a small labeled word bank so students narrate what they are doing (for example, 'I am regrouping ten ones into one ten').
  4. 4Follow a concrete-to-representational-to-abstract progression: students first act with the objects, then draw or diagram what they built, then connect it to symbols and equations, transferring the support gradually to language and notation.
  5. 5Have students manipulate the objects themselves rather than only watching, and pair or group them so they talk through the materials together, generating authentic, low-stakes academic output.
  6. 6Use the manipulatives as a formative check: observe groupings and arrangements to gauge conceptual understanding separately from English fluency, then reteach the concept rather than treating an incomplete English explanation as a content gap.
  7. 7Plan the fade: as students gain proficiency, move from physical objects to drawings to symbols, and reserve manipulatives for new or especially abstract concepts rather than every task.

Why it works for emergent bilingual students

Manipulatives let emergent bilinguals participate in rigorous, grade-level thinking before their English can fully carry that thinking, honoring the conceptual knowledge and home-language understanding they already bring rather than waiting for English to catch up. They reduce the linguistic load of a task while keeping the cognitive demand high, which is precisely the context-embedded, cognitively demanding quadrant that Cummins identifies as productive for simultaneous language and content growth (Cummins, 2000). Because the object anchors meaning, new academic vocabulary becomes comprehensible input attached to something the student can see and move, and the shared physical referent gives students a safe, concrete starting point for producing academic language with peers (Echevarría et al., 2017). Framed as a removable scaffold, manipulatives leverage what students can already do and are faded as English and symbolic reasoning grow, so they signal a stage in development rather than a deficit.

Across proficiency levels

Pre-Production

At Pre-Production, manipulatives carry most of the meaning. Students demonstrate understanding by physically showing, sorting, grouping, building, and pointing, with minimal spoken English required. The teacher names objects and actions aloud, uses gestures and home-language labels, and accepts nonverbal physical responses (arrange these tiles, build this number) as valid evidence of learning. Heavy, sustained use is expected and appropriate here.

Beginning

At Beginning, students continue to rely heavily on the objects but begin attaching single words and short phrases to their actions, supported by a labeled word bank and one-line sentence stems. They might name the manipulatives, count aloud, or complete a stem such as 'I put ___ here.' The physical support remains primary while language begins to layer onto it.

Intermediate

At Intermediate, manipulatives shift from carrying the meaning to supporting explanation. Students still use the objects but are increasingly asked to narrate and justify their actions in fuller sentences ('I regrouped because there were more than ten ones'), often moving between the concrete objects and drawings or diagrams. The teacher begins pairing each physical step with its representational and symbolic form to bridge toward abstraction.

High Intermediate / Advanced

At High Intermediate and Advanced, manipulatives are largely faded and reserved for new, complex, or especially abstract concepts (for example, introducing algebra tiles for factoring). Students reason primarily with drawings, symbols, and academic language, and may use objects briefly to verify or explain their thinking, or to model a concept for a less proficient classmate, rather than to access the task. The scaffold is occasional and strategic, not routine.

Examples

  • Math, place value: a Beginning-level student uses base-ten blocks to build two- and three-digit numbers and physically trades ten unit cubes for one rod to model regrouping, while the teacher narrates 'regroup' and the student echoes the word and points.
  • Math, fractions: at Intermediate, students use fraction tiles to compare 2/3 and 3/4, then draw the tiles and write the comparison symbol, using the stem 'I know ___ is greater because ___.'
  • Literacy, phonemic and syllable awareness: Pre-Production students push a counter or syllable card into a box for each syllable or sound in a word (so-li-da-ri-dad), segmenting orally without needing to write or define the word.
  • Grammar and sentence building: students arrange color-coded word cards (subject, verb, object) to physically construct and rearrange sentences, then read them aloud, making English word order visible and movable.
  • Science, life cycle or states of matter: students sequence picture-and-model cards or move physical models to show a process (egg to larva to pupa to adult), demonstrating the concept before labeling each stage in English.
  • Advanced fade example: a High Intermediate student briefly uses algebra tiles only to model a new factoring concept, then transitions to solving the same problems with symbols alone, explaining the reasoning to a peer who is still using the tiles.

Research basis

  • Across studies of students from kindergarten through college, instruction with concrete manipulatives produced small to moderate gains over instruction using abstract mathematical symbols alone, with the largest (moderate to large) effects on concept retention.

    Carbonneau, K. J., Marley, S. C., & Selig, J. P. (2013). A meta-analysis of the efficacy of teaching mathematics with concrete manipulatives. Journal of Educational Psychology, 105(2), 380-400. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0031084 [link]

  • Cummins frames optimal instruction for bilingual learners as cognitively demanding tasks supported by strong contextual cues (the context-embedded, cognitively demanding quadrant); manipulatives supply exactly that context-embedded support while keeping the intellectual demand high.

    Cummins, J. (2000). Language, power and pedagogy: Bilingual children in the crossfire. Multilingual Matters. https://doi.org/10.21832/9781853596773 [link]

  • Supplementary, hands-on materials and manipulatives help make grade-level content comprehensible for English learners and give them multiple, meaningful opportunities to practice and apply concepts, a core feature of sheltered instruction in the SIOP model.

    Echevarría, J., Vogt, M. E., & Short, D. J. (2017). Making content comprehensible for English learners: The SIOP model (5th ed.). Pearson.

  • Bruner argued that learning develops from action through imagery to symbols (the enactive, iconic, and symbolic modes), a theoretical basis for the concrete-to-representational-to-abstract sequence through which manipulatives are gradually faded.

    Bruner, J. S. (1966). Toward a theory of instruction. Harvard University Press.

  • The Texas ELPS adopted for implementation beginning in the 2026-2027 school year expand from four to five English language proficiency levels (Pre-Production, Beginning, Intermediate, High Intermediate, and Advanced) with revised proficiency level descriptors that guide differentiated, level-appropriate scaffolding such as manipulatives.

    Texas Education Agency. (n.d.). English language proficiency standards (ELPS) update: 2026-2027. ELPS Support Center. https://www.txel.org/media/atraqi0g/elps-update-2026-2027.pdf [link]

Sources reviewed by an independent second-language-acquisition specialist and an adversarial citation audit.

Ask Verónica about Manipulatives

Verónica is our AI tutor, and she knows this accommodation. Tell her about your classroom, your mix of proficiency levels, or a specific TEKS you are planning to teach, and she will help you put Manipulatives to work.

How do I use Manipulatives with 30 students?Adapt this for Beginning-level studentsHelp me align this to a TEKS objective
Loading Verónica…

Part of the free ELPS Online Helper. Learn the 2026 ELPS and earn 1 hour of CPE credit.

Explore the free course